Horror Sequel Marathon: Saw II (2005)

The “Saw II” poster with its severed fingers and to-the-point tagline, “Oh yes, there will be blood,” promises even more gruesome games, more sinister traps and more psychological torment. For better or for worse, “Saw II” delivers on all of the above.

“Saw II” was produced with a $5 million budget– up from the $1.2 million budget of the original. Like many horror series that begin in an isolated location, the environment in “Saw II” was greatly expanded. But the reasoning behind the shift in direction has more to do with the origin of the script, which started as a completely different film.

With the success of the original ($103.9 million at the box office), a sequel was inevitable. However, writing duo James Wan and Leigh Whannell were busy working on their next horror film, “Dead Silence.” While searching for a new script, “Saw producer Gregg Hoffman discovered director Darren Lynn Bousman, who was pitching his own movie called “The Desperate,” which other studios rejected for being too violent and similar to “Saw.” Hoffman’s partners agreed to turn Bousman’s script (with some polishing from Whannell and input from Wan) into a part of the “Saw” universe.

“Saw II” centers around two plot lines. First, Detective Matthews and a SWAT team track down “The Jigsaw Killer” John Kramer in his lair. There, Matthews discovers monitors that show that another “game” is in progress– the second plot line. One of the victims is Matthews’ son. Matthews attempts to extract information out of Kramer to helps his son, while the the eight players work their way through an elaborate house of traps and games.

Saw: The Complete Movie Collection
Saw: The Complete Movie Collection includes all seven movies and is available on DVD and blu ray right here.

The jigsaw origin story is explored further. For many fans who are primarily drawn to the series’ psychological elements, this is the most engaging part of the series. While being questioned, Jigsaw confesses that he attempted suicide after being diagnosed with terminal cancer. Upon being enlightened by the near-death experience, he decides to dedicate the rest of his life to helping others experience this same type of life-changing transformation.

“Saw II” suffers from the same kind of problems that the original (as well as Wan and Whannell’s “Dead Silence”) had. Most of the characters are generic and 2-dimensional, and the dialog is often laughably bad. Early in the film, the stereotypical macho thug snaps at the stereotypical promiscuous female, “Look who’s talking, the only door you know how to open is between ya’ legs!” Donnie Wahlberg’s portrayal of Detective Matthews is particularly poor.

But for all of the vapid dialog and overly-stylized, seizure-inducing cinematography, “Saw II” builds on the foundation of the “Saw” universe in a sadistically fascinating manner. It’s easy to dismiss the entire “Saw” franchise as torture porn garbage. But there are creative ideas and narrative innovations that redeem this and other “Saw” entries from the pitfalls associated with “torture porn” horror flicks.

Greetings… and welcome. I trust that you are all wondering where you are. I can assure you that while your location is not important, what these walls offer for your is important… salvation, if you earn it.


The mystery of the original is traded for more creative traps and “games” in the sequel. Because Jigsaw pumps toxic fumes into the rooms where the eight players fight for survival, the characters have a limited amount of time before they die of poisoning. There’s a sense of urgency in both “Saw” and “Saw II.” But in the latter, there an element of intense torment that makes the film even more difficult to watch.

Backstories also play a major role this time around. As the characters begin frantically trying to figure out how they’ll survive Jigsaw’s brutal tricks and traps, he reveals more about what they did to deserve being in their current situation. Jigsaw’s personality mirrors a messier and less sophisticated version of Kevin Spacey’s character in “Seven” and Brad Pitt’s character in “Fight Club.” But his character’s depth culminates in the sequel’s rather satisfying twist ending.

“Saw II” and other entries of the franchise benefit from a captivating over-arching narrative that’s lacking in similar films like “Hostel.” The “Saw” films are far from masterpieces, but there’s a lot to explore in the series’ many twists and turns– given that you’re able to stomach the gore.


The complete Saw collection is available on DVD, blu ray and digital download here on Amazon. And be sure to check out the other entries in the Horror Sequel Marathon right here on My Vinyl Muse!

Barry Falls Jr
Barry was the managing editor of his university newspaper before contributing as a freelance content creator for Yahoo News and Esquire. He founded Horror Theory in 2014 to analyze horror films through a sociological lens.

Latest articles

Don’t Breathe (2016): The Urban Decay of Deindustrialized Detroit and United State’s Neglect of Veterans

2016 was a big year for horror films featuring home invasions. Hush showcased Oculus director Mike Flanagan’s exhilarating twist with a hearing-impaired...

Green Room (2015): The Festering Ultra-Violent Rage of ‘Angry White Males’ in Pre-Tr*mp America

It probably is not a coincidence that, in 2016, A24 released their horror-thriller masterpiece Green Room the same month that Republican presidential...

The Invitation (2015): The Spiritual Philosophy of Bereavement and the Cult of Social Civility

Tonight is the night our faith becomes real, reads the tagline for The Invitation, the psychological horror thriller that chronicles the dinner...

We Are Still Here (2015): The Supernatural Dread of Denial, Grief, and Rural Isolationism

There’s a reason why haunted-house films are such a welcomed mainstay in the horror genre. The house as a safe space and...

The Witch (2015): The Self-Fulfilling Prophecy of Puritan Moral Panic and Patriarchal Family Dynamics

The 2010s marked a notable resurgence of religious themes and imagery in horror film. Perhaps most faithful to theological folklore was 2015’s...

It Follows (2014): Sex, Nostalgia, and The Existential Dread of Emerging Adulthood

Sex and horror have been tethered together in film since the genre's beginnings. Horror cinema remains one of the sharpest means for...



Related articles

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.